Michael Cagen, LLC

Michael Cagen, LLCMichael Cagen, LLCMichael Cagen, LLC

Michael Cagen, LLC

Michael Cagen, LLCMichael Cagen, LLCMichael Cagen, LLC
  • Home
  • About
  • Current Listings
  • Transaction History
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • About
    • Current Listings
    • Transaction History
    • Contact
Sign Up for Updates
  • Home
  • About
  • Current Listings
  • Transaction History
  • Contact
Sign Up for Updates

Transaction History Highlights

Peck Building Retail Condominiums - 40 & 52 Monroe Center St NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $2,200,000

Cap Rate: 10.92%

Closed: 01/30/26

Square Footage: 15,481

Key Tenants: Shinola, Greyson Clothiers, Gazelle Sports

Belford Building Retail Condominiums - 53, 55, & 57 Monroe Center St NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $925,000

Proforma Cap Rate: 12.46%

In-Place Cap Rate: 3.94%

Closed: 01/29/26

Square Footage: 8,635

Key Tenants: Garden District, D'Vine Nails

Jimmy John's - 63 Monroe Center St NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Closed: 10/27/25

Square Footage: 1,300

Key Tenant: Jimmy John's 

Notes: Jimmy John's has been a tenant since 2004 and exercised their Right of First Refusal

Joe's Plaza - 5293 Eastern Ave SE, Kentwood, MI

Sale Price: $1,450,000

Cap Rate: 9.25%

Closed: 01/31/23

Square Footage: 22,500

Key Tenants: Papa Murphy's Pizza, Dollar General, Admiral Tobacco

665 Seward Ave NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $14,500,000

Cap Rate: 7.90%

Closed: 12/17/21

Square Footage: 101,879

Key Tenants: Corewell Health, Edward Jones, Hooker DeJong

560 5th St NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $7,163,800

Cap Rate: 8.18%

Closed: 10/04/21

Square Footage: 108,100

Key Tenants: Argus Technologies, Emmersive Media, i3 Business Solutions

Riverbend Apartments - 29 North Drive, Union City, MI

Sale Price: $630,000

Cap Rate: 5.42%

Closed: 11/13/20

Square Footage: 21,344

Units: 28

Price per Unit: $22,500

3902 Stonegate Park, Saint Joseph, MI

Sale Price: $490,000

Closed: 05/16/19

Square Footage: 7,056

Vacant - Bank-Owned Single Tenant Office

Country Ridge Apartments - 7830 South 8th St, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $1,665,000

Cap Rate: 6.58%

Closed: 03/28/19

Square Footage: 32,436

Units: 36

Price per Unit: $46,250

Colony House Apartments - 313 West Chicago St, Coldwater, MI

Sale Price: $1,350,000

Cap Rate: 7.49%

Closed: 01/03/19

Square Footage: 29,900

Units: 33

Price per Unit: $40,909

Woodsview Apartments - 18300 US Highway 127, Cement City, MI

Sale Price: $625,000

Cap Rate: 8.40%

Closed: 11/15/18

Square Footage: 18,120

Units: 15

Price per Unit: $41,667

1315 Fraternity Village Dr, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $1,875,000

Cap Rate: 8.45%

Closed: 11/08/17

Square Footage: 23,328

Notes: Student Housing, Sold for $39,063 per Bed

30th Street Center - 3099 30th St SW, Grandville, MI

Sale Price: $1,100,000

Cap Rate: 12.22%

Closed: 08/02/17

Square Footage: 25,216

Key Tenants: Vredevoogd, Maximus Fitness, Bellagio Hair Salon

Virginia Manor Apartments - 430 N Hudson St, Coldwater, MI

Sale Price: $775,000

Cap Rate: 8.19%

Closed: 04/27/17

Square Footage: 18,284

Units: 28

Price per Unit: $27,679

West Main Place - 678 Maple Hill Drive, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $800,000

Cap Rate: 12.29%

Closed: 12/12/16

Square Footage: 20,206

Key Tenants: Allstate, Halo Hair Salon, Miller Chiropractic Clinic

Dollar General - 4395 W Monroe Road, Pentwater, MI

Sale Price: $1,300,000

Cap Rate: 6.55%

Closed: 09/02/16

Square Footage: 9,026

Notes: New Construction and New 15-Year Lease

Marlow White Uniforms - 400 Seneca St, Leavenworth, KS

Sale Price: $2,250,000

Cap Rate: 8.00%

Closed: 05/31/16

Square Footage: 27,268

Notes: Sale Leaseback with New 12-Year Lease Executed at Close

Beltline Plaza - 1680 East Apple Avenue, Muskegon, MI

Sale Price: $1,300,000

Cap Rate: 11.79%

Closed: 12/18/15

Square Footage: 79,215

Key Tenants: Dollar Tree, Plumb's

Notes: Sold via an Auction Platform

Beckley Professional Centre - 4625 Beckley Road, Battle Creek, MI

Sale Price: $2,300,000

Cap Rate: 11.04%

Closed: 11/19/15

Square Footage: 37,775

Key Tenants: Edward Jones, Pleznac Law Offices, Sylvan Learning Centers

Notes: 4 Buildings, 9 Tenants

The Lofts at 5 Lyon - 5 Lyon St NW, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $12,500,000

Cap Rate: 6.35%

Closed: 07/28/15

Square Footage: 78,300

Price per Bedroom: $75,301

Notes: 66 Units, 166 Bedrooms

Woodstone Apartments - 3707 Greenleaf Boulevard, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $4,400,000

Cap Rate: 5.42%

Closed: 01/14/15

Square Footage: 102,839

Units: 99

Price per Unit: $44,444

3301 W. Michigan, 511 Sprague, 1417 Crawford, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $1,339,000

Closed: 11/21/14

Square Footage: 37,179

Notes: Student Housing, Sold for $29,756 per Bed

Aspen Park - 810 South Farmer St, Otsego, MI

Sale Price: $1,100,000

Cap Rate: 8.55%

Closed: 05/13/14

Square Footage: 27,396

Units: 43

Price per Unit: $25,581

Thorn-Barry Apartments - 525 Lincoln St, Middleville, MI

Sale Price: $3,386,000

Cap Rate: 8.92%

Closed: 04/21/14

Square Footage: 90,400

Units: 96

Price per Unit: $35,271

Westwood Office Park - 5340 Holiday Terrace, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $2,275,000

Cap Rate: 9.21%

Closed: 04/18/14

Square Footage: 51,086

Notes: 5 Buildings, 33 Tenants

The Gate and 7-10 Bar & Grill - 706 Perry Ave, Big Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $1,000,000

Cap Rate: 13.52%

Closed: 07/19/13

Square Footage: 38,625

Key Tenants: The Gate, 7-10 Bar & Grill

Notes: Bank-Owned

Maple Brooke Apartments - 4632 Beech Ave, Kalamazoo, MI

Sale Price: $2,150,000

Cap Rate: 10.08%

Closed: 07/11/13

Square Footage: 58,352

Units: 64

Price per Unit: $33,594

Family Dollar Retail Center - 1253 Lincoln Road, Allegan, MI

Sale Price: $530,000

Cap Rate: 8.68%

Closed: 03/29/13

Square Footage: 19,200

Key Tenants: Family Dollar, Russell Cellular/Verizon

Park Place Apartments - 615-628 John Anderson Court, Monroe, MI

Sale Price: $450,000

Cap Rate: 11.78%

Closed: 08/30/12

Square Footage: 49,896

Units: 53

Price per Unit: $8,491

Notes: Bank-Owned, Partially Converted to Condominium

A Northland Drive Spare Room - 12505 Northland Dr, Cedar Springs, MI

Sale Price: $500,000

Cap Rate: 11.12%

Closed: 05/14/12

Square Footage: 60,981

Units: 299

Notes: Bank-Owned Self-Storage Facility, Only 29% Leased at Closing

10 Mile Road Spare Room - 505 10 Mile Road, Sparta, MI

Sale Price: $300,000

Cap Rate: 10.68%

Closed: 05/14/12

Square Footage: 34,648

Price per Unit: $1,333

Notes: Bank-Owned Self-Storage Facility, Only 45% Leased at Closing 

Orchard Place - 1300 Knapp St NE, Grand Rapids, MI

Sale Price: $5,500,000

Cap Rate: 8.80%

Closed: 11/01/11

Square Footage: 138,246

Units: 138

Price per Unit: $39,855

Notes: Affordable Housing with PILOT in place

Airport Self Storage - 4570 36th St SE, Kentwood, MI

Sale Price: $475,000

Cap Rate: 6.28%

Closed: 05/06/11

Square Footage: 41,275

Price per Unit: $1,870

Notes: Bank-Owned Self-Storage Facility, Only 57% Leased at Closing

Advance Auto Parts - 3133 East Michigan Ave, Jackson, MI

Sale Price: $810,000

Cap Rate: 11.41%

Closed: 10/04/10

Square Footage: 7,000

Notes: Sale with 4 Years Remaining in Lease, with Multiple Renewal Options

North Muskegon Apartments - 1011 Ruddiman, North Muskegon, MI

Sale Price: $460,000

Cap Rate: 2.88%

Closed: 05/07/10

Square Footage: 21,098

Units: 34

Price per Unit: $13,529

Notes: Receiver Controlled, Distressed Asset

Grand Haven Club - 14868 Lakeshore Dr, Grand Haven, MI

Sale Price: $4,500,000

Proforma Cap Rate: 6.49%

Closed: 04/30/10

Square Footage: 198,930

Units: 182

Price per Unit: $24,725

Notes: Receiver Controlled, Distressed Asset, Partial Condo Conversion, Millions of Unfinished Construction

Quest Diagnostics - 2740 28th St SW, Wyoming, MI

Sale Price: $3,050,000

Cap Rate: 9.53%

Closed: 08/06/08

Square Footage: 25,506

Walgreen's - 3191 28th St, Grandville, MI

Sale Price: $1,850,000

Cap Rate: 7.83%

Closed: 11/08/07

Square Footage: 13,000

Notes: Tenant is Still There in 2026

Family Dollar White Cloud - 32 S. Charles St, White Cloud, MI

Sale Price: $625,000

Cap Rate: 8.80%

Closed: 12/15/06

Square Footage: 11,600

Copyright © 2026 Michael Cagen, L.L.C. - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Home
  • About
  • Current Listings
  • Transaction History
  • Sign Up For Updates
  • Contact

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept